Cultural Relativism and Child Labor - 2633 Words

Cultural Relativism and Child Labor Child Labor The use of child labor in developing nations is not a moral issue, it is a cultural one. International corporations should not let the moral argument or current legislation such as the Child Labor Deterrence Act (CLDA) influence how and where they conduct operations. Grounded in what appears as legitimate concern for children, proposed legislation such as the CLDA hinder the potential growth and progress of developing nations by limiting the number of corporations who are willing to set up operations within developing countries. The fallacy with CLDA and similar legislation is that they based on a one-sided moral perspective that inhibits change in developing countries by preventing†¦show more content†¦The relative viewpoint of the culture is paramount because the only way to affect change is from within. The saying, â€Å"(w)hen in Rome, do as the Romans do† should initially be applied when dealing with developing countries whose moral norms conflict wit h those of developed countries until real change can be imposed. When applied to the child labor debate it can be argued that the utilization of child labor is a necessary step in the evolution of culture, society, and developing country. The most social and economically responsible thing to do is to assist developing countries by promoting foreign and domestic business development through capital investment to the point where child labor is no longer required to sustain the economy. While this is in contradiction with the common belief that child labor is exploitative or a form of indentured servitude and slavery is what paved the way for the CLDA. The CLDA, also known as the Harkin Bill would have prohibited the import ofShow MoreRelatedThe Importance Of Cultural Relativism801 Words   |  4 Pagesphilosophy known as Cultural Relativism. Cultural Relativism is based on the idea that morality is based only on the culture that we were brought up in. It states that there is no unive rsal moral truth to be used to determine if something is right or wrong, so it is unfair to criticize another’s moral actions, because we did not have the same cultural upbringing as ourselves. In this paper, I will be using an reductio approach to show that the consequences of accepting Cultural Relativism as a valid schoolRead MoreRelativism, Multiculturalism, And Universal Norms866 Words   |  4 PagesAni Martirosyan Philosophy 305 Business Ethics Assignment #4 Chapter 8: Relativism, Multiculturalism, And Universal Norms: Their Role in Business Ethics The central thesis of Beauchamp’s argument is as follows: I argue that although a relativism of all moral standards is an untenable position, a lower-level relativism of moral judgment and multiculturalism are morally warranted. I conclude that there is a universal common morality, but that it allows for moral disagreement and legitimate differencesRead MoreRelativism, Multiculturalism, And Universal Norms866 Words   |  4 PagesAni Martirosyan Philosophy 305 Business Ethics Assignment #4 Chapter 8: Relativism, Multiculturalism, And Universal Norms: Their Role in Business Ethics The central thesis of Beauchamp’s argument is as follows: I argue that although a relativism of all moral standards is an untenable position, a lower-level relativism of moral judgment and multiculturalism are morally warranted. I conclude that there is a universal common morality, but that it allows for moral disagreement and legitimate differencesRead MoreComing From The Republic Of Ghana1527 Words   |  7 PagesComing from The Republic of Ghana, I know firsthand that sweatshops and the child labor that takes place in them can be both dehumanizing and destructive. However, I also understand the benefits of sweatshops. Despite all the facts that prove that sweatshops and the child labor that happens in them are bad, the truth of the matter is that some places have now become so dependent on the income they are receiving from sweatshops that there is no alternative in their minds. In addition, some kids haveRead MoreEssay on Ethics: Where Do We Learn What Constitutes Right o r Wrong?953 Words   |  4 Pagesby our value systems and how we determine right and wrong. However, in all three of these schools of thought there is one underlying commonality: ethical relativism deems that a person’s values and judgments are based upon their cultural and societal influences and their personal feelings. (DesJardins, 2011) Ethical Relativism Ethical relativism simply stated, is that our upbringing and the culture we are raised in influences how we make a judgment with regards to what we deem to label with the titlesRead MoreCultural Relativism in Business1590 Words   |  7 Pages Topic: Cultural Relativism In Business Submitted to: Mr. Mehmood Ul Hassan Khalil Submitted by: Waqas Shehzad Class: BBA 5D Cultural Relativism: Cultural relativism is the view that all beliefs are equally valid and that truth itself is relative, depending on the situation, environment, and individual. Those who hold to cultural relativism hold that all religious, ethical, aesthetic, and political beliefs are completely relative to the individual within a cultural identity. Cultural relativismRead MoreAct Utilitarian1168 Words   |  5 Pagesutilitarian’s judge actions in terms of the goodness of their consequences without reference to rules of action. Example of Rule Utilitarian Think of a situation of a man and his pregnant girlfriend driving down the street. She suddenly goes into labor when her water breaks. The contractions are close at about 2 minutes apart. It is 4am on a Friday night. The vehicle is 2 miles from the hospital. There are no other cars around. The Rule Utilitarian would think if you were as a rule to break the lawRead MoreHuman Behavior, Ethnocentrism, And Cultural Relativism1466 Words   |  6 Pageshuman behavior, ethnocentrism and cultural relativism will be examined as these concepts expose the authors (McDonnell 2016). Male domination will also be considered while examining these concepts as an important trait in the Afghan society. Ethnocentrism is an idea supported by a mixture of beliefs that one’s own culture is superior to any other culture. The ideas, foreign ways, and values of them are less human or less rational (McDonnell 2016). Cultural relativism, on the other hand, is the understandingRead MoreEssay on Literary Analysis: Some Moral Minima866 Words   |  4 Pagesmade an effort to distinguish relativism from pluralism. Which he named four: respect for life, deference to truth, abhorrence of theft, and rejection of adultery which where are worthy of universal support. (Goodman, 2010, p. 89). Goodman, then goes on to listing four areas of relativism and morals in which he feels are just wrong and should be eliminated. They are (1) genocide, politically, induced famine, and germ warfare; (2) terrorism, hostage taking, and child warriors; (3) slavery, polygamyRead MoreEssay about Business Ethics1439 Words   |  6 Pagessupplier/customer relations, business owners must consider whether it is ethical to do business with a supplier that has unethical practices. For example a clothing store must decide if they will continue to do business with a supplier who utilizes child labor. Businesses must also ensure that they do not falsely advertise products or services or produce anything sub-standard for clients. Recent Trends in Business Ethics Whistleblowing is becoming a trend. Employees seem to be more willing these days